Roof Replacements- What Homeowners Need to Know

By September 20th, 2025Homeowner Tips, Judi's Blog6 min read
Roof Replacements Checklist | Judi Wright Team

Home-ownership can be a fantastic experience filled with lots of joy and pride. For most homeowners, however, roof replacement projects are not something they usually enjoy.

Roof Replacements – A Homeowner’s Guide

Given the numerous storms in Texas, it’s likely that almost everyone’s roof in the area will need replacement at some point. But roof repairs and replacements can be an expensive endeavor, costing an average of around $10,000 for small to medium-sized homes. This is a pretty significant investment, so make sure that you’re getting the best bang for your buck with the following tips!

How to know if you need a replacement

Some indicators, like visible cracks and leaking, are a sure sign it’s time to replace your roof. But how do you know when the right time is if your roof looks fine overall? The first question you need to ask is how old your current roof is. The average lifespan is 20-25 years, so it might be time to have it inspected if you are approaching that. Another indicator is if you can see missing shingles, moss, or mold growth. These issues shouldn’t be ignored, as water damage can cause your roof to sag, leading to a significantly higher replacement bill.

Choose the best materials

Roofs should be a one-time investment that’ll last as long as you live in this house. So don’t skimp on the quality -go for quality materials. Adding an extra thousand or so dollars to get lasting materials like 50-year shingles with copper flashing can ensure that you won’t ever have to deal with replacing the roof again! As a bonus, your house will sport a more architectural look versus traditional asphalt shingles. Avoid stretching your wallet in the future for another roof replacement by choosing better quality today.

Should you layer or replace?

Take advantage of the roof replacement to inspect the supporting plywood. More often than not, the old decking will be worn out and need patchwork or even replacement. While it might be tempting to layer on top of your current roof, especially if your shingles are not asphalt, the cons far outweigh the pros. The aging support plywood may not be able to support the additional weight of the second layer of shingles. The original layer can also start curling, making the surface highly uneven and putting your new roof layer in danger of sliding off. Even though removing the original layer might require you to strip the plywood decking completely, consider replacing instead of layering, which could save you significant time in the long run.

Look around for the best contractor

There are plenty of roofing contractors to choose from, so make sure you shop around and get quotes from various businesses for your project before choosing. It may be tempting to go for the company that offers you the cheapest prices, but you’ll be getting what you pay for and most likely regret it soon after.

Unfortunately, there are many unscrupulous roofing companies running roofing scams on homeowners. Be very cautious of the following:

  • Storm chasers– these companies send reps into neighborhoods recently hit by storms ,offering significant discounts and fast repairs. Often, the homeowner is left with subpar repairs or even paying for unnecessary repairs or replacements.
  • No deductible– Any roofing company that offers to handle your insurance claim or pay your deductible for you is a red flag. This means they will either take shortcuts on the repairs or increase the amount charged to your insurance company.
  • Lowest bids – Roofing companies often offer the lowest bid by either lowering the quality of the materials they use or the quality of the workers they employ. When investing in a long-term project like roofing, it’s crucial to sign a contract with a company only after conducting thorough research on their reviews.
  • Unlicensed contractors – Always check to ensure the roofing company you select is licensed in your state (if required in your state) and fully covered with liability insurance. You may get a great quote and a promise of ‘lots of experience,’ but these contractors should be avoided.
  • Asking for complete payment upfront – You should never pay for the total cost of the job upfront, with any contractor, much less roofing companies. Payments should be established upfront at the contract stage, with the final payment released after the roof passes inspection.

In general, it is best to work through your homeowner’s insurance company for roof repairs and replacements to help protect you against roofing scams. Additionally, check the Better Business Bureau for reports on any contractor you are considering before a contract is signed.

Plan for the work

Roof replacement is a very loud procedure and involves a lot of hammering. If you have kids or pets in the house, plan ahead and make reservations to stay somewhere else to avoid headaches from the noise. It’s also a good practice to let your neighbors know of the upcoming work and to expect a few loud days.

Cleanup

Removing your shingles or plywood will create a clutter of nails and debris. Talk with your contractor beforehand to make sure that they will be taking care of this before they leave. They have a powerful magnet that can quickly and safely clear the mess, so you don’t have to worry about your feet or tires.

Make sure all the documents are in order

Roof replacements are a significant undertaking, so in addition to the actual roofing contract, you will need a building permit to ensure your roof warranty remains valid. Don’t forget to get proof that the contractor’s insurance company covers your project.

Want more information on roofing contractors in our area? Give us a call; we’ll be happy to provide you with a copy of our Homeowner Supplier Resource Guide.


About Judi Wright – Trusted Real Estate Expert

With over 50 years of experience in the Dallas-Fort Worth area and 23 years as a Real Estate agent, Judi is one of North Texas’ most trusted and accomplished real estate professionals. As an award-winning Top Realtor, she has built a reputation for excellence, integrity, and personalized service throughout Collin, Dallas and Denton counties (and beyond). Judi treats every client like family and works hard to deliver an experience worth recommending. References and testimonials are available upon request and Judi would be honored to earn your business.